However, Jamie decides to seek out Garrett, who reveals that Jamies mother was a drug addict, and he killed Phyllis to protect his son from a bad upbringing. On the certificate were two strange names, and this left Jamie puzzled as he had always believed he was born by the Duttons. Sure, there's the name issue, but entirely possible he changed his name . While on the ranch, Garrett tells Jamie he loves him while taking in the sites. If the answer is yes to any of that Im your guy! Claire is prim and proper, and hypercritical of her brother and his family. Instead of having John and Evelyn Dutton as his parents, his parents are instead listed as Garrett and Phyllis Randall. However, John explained to Jamie that his biological mother was killed before she got a chance to show him how much she loved him. The next generation of the Duttons is there as well, as John and his late wife, Evelyn, had kids of their own. However, there is very little information known about Phyllis and her relationship with the Duttons. For example, the Duttons are a prominent local family, with John Dutton, as livestock commissioner, effectively a public figure. His allegiance has been bought through blackmail and after he's killed his biological dad, at least Beth will never believe he'd freely stay loyal to anyone. Yellowstones Kelly Reilly says that Beth Dutton could never forgive her brother, Wes Bentleys Jamie Dutton, as its simply not in her character. They have no biological children of their own and are not in the direct lineage of the current Dutton clan. I really hope there is no family connection because it seems like a cop-out, another Redditor proclaims. In season three, Jamie needed his birth certificate, but on receiving it, he discovered that his parents, John and Evelyn Dutton, were not his biological parents. Anthonys favorite movie genre is Horror. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Jamie is the only child NOT ALLOWED to follow his own interests, but rather, was ordered to go to Harvard and study the law. Others think John Dutton and Garrett Randall made a pact for John to raise Jamie. Jamie is the adopted son of John and Evelyn, and the biological son of Garrett Randall, who allegedly killed his birth mother. YELLOWSTONE's latest season was one to be remembered as it was filled to the brim with unexpected twists and turns. Learn More. Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. While Beth tells Rip she is not able to have children, she does not go into detail. It seems odd that a couple with the social standing of the Duttons would be that closely involved with simply a casual neighbor or friend.. John Dutton, the family patriarch, had three children with his late wife, Evelyn. He also wants Jamie to challenge John Dutton in the race for the Montana Governor position. Yes! Upon being released from jail, Garrett tells Jamie that he killed his mother to save Jamies life. Why did John Dutton and his wife adopt Jamie? John says that he knew Jamies mother Phyllis, Who Plays Jamie on Yellowstone? After learning the truth about his heritage, Jamie meets Garrett. He responded, saying, I protected you, I guided you, I loved you, you can call me whatever you want, Jamie, but I will call you son because I have earned the right. However, the Dutton family doesn't. When Jamie finally took action, it was an attempt to side with the Duttons and preserve his own standing. As John Dutton Junior came into the mix, Elsa is Costners characters great aunt. Does Jamie sleep with Lord John? To restart or refresh, he definitely has left himself an open door for a lot of options. However, the plan may have backfired on him. The following contains spoilers for Yellowstone Season 5, Episode 2 "The Sting of Wisdom," which debuted Sunday, Nov. 13 on Paramount Network. Though I think they could explore that with Jimmys death. Yellowstone's spin-offs, 1883 and 1923, both offer a more detailed look into the current seven generations of the Dutton family. Jamie is a lawyer who uses his position as a means to protect his family. In a tear-jerking scene with the two men, John tells Jamie hes earned the right to call the latter his son. Elsas future appears dismal in the opening scene of 1883. It is an interesting and logical theory as the scene seemingly foreshadows Jamies discovery in season three. Yellowstone: Why Did Jamie Dutton Kill His Dad? This post may contain affiliate links. As an audience, it feels like the board got wiped and we can write some new things on that board.. She is also a shrewd businesswoman and protector of the family. Many fans believe there is a connection that has yet to be revealed through nearly four seasons. And because this is one of the few shows in which that phrase might be taken literally, allow me to clarify: Elsa gets married in Sundays episode. His parents' names were Garrett (Will Patton) and Phyllis Randall,. After some time, Garrett is able to bond with his son, expressing that he is proud of him. Jamie and Garrett form a bond almost immediately after their first meeting. He's always treated Jamie as someone there to SERVE him and the family interests. Jaime Dutton (Wes Bentley) is the only adopted member of the Dutton family. What are your thoughts?. They have grown quite a bit closer this season as their relationship continues to evolve. He is just a child in 1883, but is a grown man by the events of 1923. Jamie eventually kills his biological father and has an estranged relationship with John after being disinherited. They have since reconciled due to John wanting to be close to his grandson, Tate. It is likely that John Dutton adopted Jamie since he knew the Randall family and wanted to protect Jamie from any further harm. Garrett spent 30 years in jail for murdering Phyllis and Jamie spent that time being raised by John and Evelyn Dutton. The following morning, both talk about Jamie and admit they are using each other to connect with Jamie's memory. Garrett was later convicted for the death of Phyllis and sentenced to 30 years in prison. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Jamies mother might be a Dutton herself, another fan speculates. Apparently, Phyllis didnt always have such a troubling past. In the section where it reads identification of adopting parents, he spots John Dutton's (Kevin Costner) name. In a state of dismay, he confronts his adopted father, John Dutton, who shares details about the events that led to his adoption. John told Jamie that we (meaning he and his wife Evelyn) tried to talk Jamies mother out of marrying Randall, but she was in love and wouldnt listen, the fan posted. Fury of the Gods Special: Shazamily Matters, Stranger Things Prequel Trailer Sets Up Vecna's Ominous Origin Story, Two Rings of Power Characters Will Change Their Names in Season 2, Star Wars Fans Are Convinced The Mandalorian Just Teased a Major Rebels Return. Spencer Dutton, John Duttons younger brother, is now a teenager. The son of James and Margaret Dutton, John was only a child when his family founded their homestead in Montanathe land that would ultimately become the Yellowstone Dutton ranch. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Meet Wes Bentley. In the season 4 finale, Beth finally got the revenge she had been looking for, and now her father owns Jamie. One of the most unexpected twists in the Dutton family saga is the one about the true parentage of Jamie Dutton. Jamie was born as James Michael Randall to a couple named Garrett Randall and Phyllis Mary Randall, who had quite a rough marriage. Jaimes true family had been concealed from him by John Dutton (Kevin Costner) until he discovered his adoption papers while trying to file for his role as Montanas attorney general. Jamie Dutton Sr. (Wes Bentley) is a complicated family member. But I guess she thought she could save him. John Dutton Sr., originally known as John Dutton, is a main character in 1883: A Yellowstone Origin Story. If Duttons sister-in-law was brutally murdered, it would have been impossible to keep that quiet and the local newspapers would have had a field day. To keep it a secret from the community, Jamie drove her to an Indian Health Clinic on the nearby reservation. Now, fans are . Without a doubt, this truth is bound to affect how things unfold in the upcoming fourth season. Jamie Dutton may have been safe during the devastating attacks on the Duttons in the Season 3 finale, but he is still in grave danger. That was certainly the case in season three as we learn that Jamie Dutton is not an actual Yellowstone Ranch Dutton. One day, Garrett got home from work only to discover young Jamie crying and sucking on a crack pipe. Claire Dutton (Dawn Olivieri) was the sister of James Dutton and the aunt of Elsa, John, and Spencer. Handsome Sam, the Comanche man she met [checks notes] last episode. Powered by Reelgood. MITs Alan , In 2020, as a response to the disruption caused by COVID-19, the College Board modified the AP exams so they were shorter, administered online, covered less material, and had a different format than previous tests. Jamie kills his dad after he receives an ultimatum from Beth. Our readers support us. James is John Dutton III's (Kevin Costner) great-grandfather. What will emerge about Jamies backstory in Season 4? Who is Jamie Dutton? Next: What Order To Watch Yellowstone & Its Many Spinoffs. After weeks of teasing a showdown, Lloyd finally attacks Walker for real, smashing his guitar and stabbing him in the upper chest with a knife. Jamie then takes Garretts body to the train station to dispose of it. The couple had three kids; Elsa, John, and Spencer. Despite growing closer to his father, Jamie shoots him in the head because of Beths blackmail. Jennifer Landons Future Explained. He worked the Yellowstone land. However, John's story doesn't have a happy ending, as he is killed early on in 1923. His parents names were Garrett (Will Patton) and Phyllis Randall, and his father murdered his mother when Jamie was just a baby. However, Beth wouldnt budge, which led Jamie to come to the conclusion that the best choice would be to kill his father himself. Beth's actions at the end of Yellowstone Season 4 and into Season 5 are pushing Jamie too far. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. The family originally had plans to relocate to Oregon by way of the Oregon trail until Elsa's death at the end of 1883 season 1. Do you want to have philosophical debates about Star Wars? When taking Garretts corpse to the train station to dispose of it, Beth catches Jamie in the acting and takes a photo of Jamie holding his dads corpse as evidence flor blackmail. John Dutton said in season three, When he married the woman who gave birth to you, we begged her not to do it because we knew. The adopted son has always had a complicated relationship with his father, Yellowstone patriarch John Dutton ( Kevin Costner ). 1883 introduces the patriarch and matriarch of the Dutton Family in James (Tim Mcgraw) and Margaret (Faith Hill). 0. One would assume that these similarities between the father-son duo stem from their blood relation. Yellowstone is an American neo-Western drama television series created by Taylor Sheridan and John Linson that premiered on June 20, 2018, on Paramount Network.The series stars Kevin Costner, Luke Grimes, Kelly Reilly, Wes Bentley, Cole Hauser, Kelsey Asbille, and Gil Birmingham.The series follows the conflicts along the shared borders of the Yellowstone Ranch, a large cattle ranch, the Broken . Garrett hit Phyllis to the point that she died. She passed away not far into the trip, as she died by suicide after bandits killed her daughter. Prior to the incident, Garrett and Randall were bonding, with Garrett telling Jamie he loves him. Bentley was as curious as everyone else. Yellowstone: The Surprising Theory That Ties Jamies Biological Dad to the Duttons. All season long, fans have debated which of the 1923 characters will turn out to be the parents of John Dutton II, the future father of Yellowstone's patriarch, with Spencer and Alex being primary contenders along with Spencer's nephew Jack and his wife Elizabeth.While Elizabeth's pregnancy seemed to make them the more likely choice in recent episodes, the finale saw her sadly suffer a . Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. When Jamie was three months old, John and Evelyn Dutton adopted him. Who did Jamie get pregnant on Yellowstone? Jamie came from a more troubling family that had their own secrets. Popular Paramount Network series, "Yellowstone," ended its third season with the truth about Jamie Dutton's birth mother.